ok everyone ive got a question that ive been wanting to ask fo a long time.who do you think is the better quarterback in the nfl.
tom brady or payton manning>.my guess is tom brady.........whats yours.

tom brady

but i am a cowboys fan!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Brett Favre... oh wait he's not on the list

payton manning!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

payton...go blue!!!!

im a steelers fan myself.but i still think tom brady is the better quarterback............ go steelers.....

peyton manning. i am a huge peyton manning fan..even named my son after him
Becca

ok i will agree payton manning is good,but i guess we will find out in two weeks just who is the better quarterback.patriots---colts.a battle of the undefeated.whatever team wins that game will win the superbowl.....do you agree.

brady- super bowl wins
petyon-talent
just like bill russell vs wilt chamberlain
russell- all those nba titles

Peyton Manning, hands down.

Tom Brady benefits more from the "system" of the Patriots.

Let the two QBs switch teams.

Peyton would still be awesome, even more so because of the offensive weapons he'd had access to.

Brady would still be an above-average QB, but not the "awesome force" he's potrayed as in the media.

Before I get hate posts over this, let me say that I feel Brady is the 2nd best QB in the league. I simply feel that, all things being equal, Peyton's just a little bit better.

Well said Knox and I agree with you.

Joe Montana in his prime would have been average if placed on the early Buccaneers squads. It's not about 1 guy in football. You don't have the supporting staff it doesn't matter how good you are.

Peyton.

Payton Manning most def. GO BLUE

they both kik a$$. but we wont know till thier careers r over. But if u go by the numbers? 18 is the man

also is u count rings that makes it 3 to 1 in favor of brady. as a colts fan im calling it a tie untill they r both done playing

teams win championships, players don't

the better quaterback is def peyton manning. dont get me wrong tom brady is a hell of a qb but peyton manning reads defensives better and has a way better arm than brady does. peyton can throw in between 3 defenders and tom brady cant. thats the difference.

This year Brady has the better numbers. However, Manning has had the better numbers pretty much the rest of the time.

Well find out on Nov. 4th.


GO COLTS!!!!!

<--------- cowboys fan

peyton manning