Topic: the better quarterback
Brykers23's photo
Wed 10/24/07 07:50 AM
Tom Brady he does more with less as far as talent goes, this guy sat behind Brian Griese at Michigan for two years and then split time with Drew Henson.

Peyton is a great QB but I give the edge to Brady 3 Super Bowl Wins to 1 for Peyton

Mac6556's photo
Wed 10/24/07 09:09 AM
u cant go by superbowl wins.....cuz if u did dan marino wuld mean nuttin....and in basketball ball doctor jay who is prob one of da best basketball players to ever play i only think he had one championship...so if u think he better cuz he has mre superbowl wins den dat a bad reason

Fanta46's photo
Wed 10/24/07 09:53 AM
Peyton Manning, no doubt!!drinker

Fanta46's photo
Wed 10/24/07 09:55 AM
Who's the best ever?

I say Elway!!!drinker

astrosfan's photo
Wed 10/24/07 09:56 AM
hmm becca is one ture fan then ...

um .. you guys forgot to mention a quarter back who only threw one interception all yr long . from the jaguars .. ..
but the colts are bad ass
have to peyton because colts have has the coldest offensive
players scoring 35 plus points a game ..

no photo
Wed 10/24/07 12:35 PM
The colts have one of the best defenses in football and who from the Jaguars? Garrard LMAO he isn't even a top 10 quarterback. Brady might become better then Manning but he didn't put up great numbers until he got the receivers. Manning always puts up freak numbers and is probably the greatest quarterback of all time.

Mac6556's photo
Wed 10/24/07 05:08 PM
lol dats funni u think brady hasnt put up numbers i think peyton is better and always will be....but tom brady has neva had recievers and always been a top qb and has neva had a runing game and peyton has always had the recievers and da running game... and da colts defense has us started gettin good last year dey were good but dis year der not da best... da jaguars defense is one of da best defense in da league

andrewzooms's photo
Sat 10/27/07 09:53 AM
They are both as good as each other. There is no way you can compare the greatness of both.

Jtevans's photo
Sat 10/27/07 10:26 AM
John Elway!


wait,he retired???crap!ohwell

txmama74's photo
Sat 10/27/07 10:56 AM
laugh laugh laugh

andrewzooms's photo
Sat 10/27/07 11:22 AM
Joe Montana is still the best.

drv4269's photo
Sun 10/28/07 09:47 AM
glasses
TONY ROMO
BUT MANNING IS GOOD ALSO

wait rex grossman i love his style

andrewzooms's photo
Sun 10/28/07 01:24 PM
Big game next week.

Eljay's photo
Sun 10/28/07 06:10 PM
Without a doubt - Tom Brady. Peyton is a lock hall of fame - 1st ballad entry. Tom is the GOAT.

dhutch9's photo
Mon 10/29/07 05:40 PM
Tom Brady is better. Peyton is only good because of the awesome colts offensive line. I'm a Rams fan unfortunately. Do we even have a quarterback?

Dayv's photo
Mon 10/29/07 06:28 PM
Statistically Manning owns Brady, Brady is having a good year that's for sure.
and peyton is not only good cause he has a great offensive line, he broke many records before they got thier sh*t together, we'll see how well he shines when they finally play a decent team.

Dayv's photo
Mon 10/29/07 06:34 PM
http://www.sportspool.com/football/nfl_history/nfl_football_league_records_player1.php

if ya go there and check out All time quartbacks, Brady is NOT listed even 1 time, Manning is listed several times, like I said, Statistically speaking, Brady falls short.

Eljay's photo
Mon 10/29/07 11:38 PM
Davy;

Last time I checked - winning percentage was a stat Tom Brady is the winniest quarterback in NFL history. Regular season AND Post season.

kayd4's photo
Tue 10/30/07 07:16 PM
both r good but id have to go with brady on that one

vardlokkur's photo
Tue 10/30/07 07:18 PM
I'd have to go with Peyton