Previous 1
Topic: Whitney Houston or maria carey
livin4theDream's photo
Thu 11/18/10 09:05 AM
which one was the best intheir prime????

RowBaby's photo
Thu 11/18/10 09:26 AM
Whitney!

msharmony's photo
Thu 11/18/10 09:32 AM
Whitney had more soul, Mariah had more range,,,

diz08's photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:40 PM
I agree with harmony.
I have a dream that one day, I will be so lucky in this life, to put this list of women in studio or on stage TOGETHER:
Whitney
Mariah
Martina McBride
Christina Aguilera

Just so I can hear how amazing those powerful voices would sound together.

no photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:44 PM
was? mariah carey is still very much in her prime and as awesome as ever

emancipation of mimi was fab-u-lous!! I love her w/ JZ. there is no one else like mariah she's awesome and 1 of a kind

if we're lucky her "prime" will just continue on & on...

one of my life dream's is to see mariah carey on concert - I'd freak at the chance

newarkjw's photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:45 PM
Good lord that's my only choices......smokin

no photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:46 PM

Whitney had more soul, Mariah had more range,,,


I agree Mariah sings more R&B than soul, and Whitney was also wonderful in her time

anyway Mariah has Opera in her background which may explain her range to some extent - her mom sang opera

no photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:48 PM

Good lord that's my only choices......smokin


well, are there any female R&B songstresses u prefer to those two - let's hear from ya!!!

I also particularly like Tina Turner and Kim Weston but both are soul

diz08's photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:48 PM
would love to see whitney make a great comeback! And yes, Mariah is amazing and yet to reach her prime. I think she will be better after she has her baby.

no photo
Thu 11/18/10 06:49 PM
Edited by sweetestgirl11 on Thu 11/18/10 06:53 PM
well and I cant leave out Madonna - I think she's fab but w/ of course her own style - but I think her hype got so much attention that we forgot to listen - she can sing


A mariah baby - cool!! I forgot she was prego

no photo
Fri 11/26/10 03:03 AM
Edited by Wizard_27 on Fri 11/26/10 03:04 AM
Whitney was outstanding! "I will always love you" is one of the best soulful song I've ever heard.

newarkjw's photo
Fri 11/26/10 03:16 AM
Edited by newarkjw on Fri 11/26/10 04:09 AM


Good lord that's my only choices......smokin


well, are there any female R&B songstresses u prefer to those two - let's hear from ya!!!

I also particularly like Tina Turner and Kim Weston but both are soul


Aretha Franklin and Bonnie Rait come to mind.....smokin

Bonnie Raitt - I Can't Make You Love Me

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMU6J-MWT8E


Aretha Franklin - Think

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0y2dDlFmLg

newarkjw's photo
Fri 11/26/10 05:35 AM
I know she was a mousekateer but she has soul........smokin

Save Me From Myself - Christina Aguilera

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GNwcqr7TzQ

TuTesoro's photo
Sat 12/04/10 01:23 AM
not enough Mariah lovin.......my vote is for Mariah

msharmony's photo
Sat 12/04/10 01:32 AM
I think of whitney as a soulful singer, not alot of gimmick beyond her soulful voice


I think of mariah as an incredible vocalist who uses too much gimmick instead of a soulful voice,,

zunelander's photo
Fri 04/08/11 07:28 PM

Whitney had more soul, Mariah had more range,,,


That's interesting since I can recall hearing things said about Whitney like how she didn't sound black or soulful enough. Too pop/white sounding. Of course, in my book, music has no color. Music is just music. No white or black music. But, humans. You know how we can be:)

mightymoe's photo
Fri 04/08/11 07:43 PM



Good lord that's my only choices......smokin


well, are there any female R&B songstresses u prefer to those two - let's hear from ya!!!

I also particularly like Tina Turner and Kim Weston but both are soul


Aretha Franklin and Bonnie Rait come to mind.....smokin

Bonnie Raitt - I Can't Make You Love Me

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMU6J-MWT8E


Aretha Franklin - Think

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0y2dDlFmLg


AF has the prettiest voice ever... a close runner up (IMO)would be Sheena Easton.... Whitney Houston was one of the best looking ladies i have ever seen, till she met bobby numbnuts brown...

Simonedemidova's photo
Fri 04/08/11 08:04 PM
I have to admit, WHITNEY was my idol growing up, but crack F'D her up bad. I have no respect for her anymore. She sounds and looks like crap.

I've always been a fan of Mariah since her very first album and I still love listening to her, I even had my ex make me mix of all my favorite Mariah songs. So as long as Mariah steers clear of crack, and I think she will with her nice husband who worships her and now her twins---I always Love and respect MARIAH more.

msharmony's photo
Sat 04/09/11 12:12 PM


Whitney had more soul, Mariah had more range,,,


That's interesting since I can recall hearing things said about Whitney like how she didn't sound black or soulful enough. Too pop/white sounding. Of course, in my book, music has no color. Music is just music. No white or black music. But, humans. You know how we can be:)



wow, thats the first time I EVER heard that ,,,,interesting.

mightymoe's photo
Sat 04/09/11 12:26 PM



Whitney had more soul, Mariah had more range,,,


That's interesting since I can recall hearing things said about Whitney like how she didn't sound black or soulful enough. Too pop/white sounding. Of course, in my book, music has no color. Music is just music. No white or black music. But, humans. You know how we can be:)



wow, thats the first time I EVER heard that ,,,,interesting.


"How will i know" was a very pretty song, she sounded and looked like a goddess.... never cared about her color or if she sounded like a certain color, the song was just wonderful.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Luf9VBwnRPM

such a happy song

Previous 1