Topic: Is faith stronger than religion?
causality's photo
Fri 08/07/09 08:00 AM
once i have it pegged, i will be making a large multi-media presentation to share the truth i find with any who care to hear it and know ALL THAT IS.

no photo
Fri 08/07/09 12:42 PM

I have faith the sun will rise, tomorrow.
How ever, I do not worship the sun.



You don't need faith for something that is readily provable.

no photo
Fri 08/07/09 12:44 PM

Faith is nothing more than expectation, is it not?

If you have no expections then there is no reason to have faith.

Even faith in a doctrine is nothing more than an expectation that the doctrine is true.

Faith in a higher power is nothing more than an expectation that a higher power exists.

Faith in yourself is nothing more than having expectations of yourself.

Faith = Expectation.

Religion on the other hand seems to be a highly ill-defined word.

Some people like Tanyaann obviously view religion as 'doctrine'.

Other people view religion as simply anything that is practiced 'religiousity' (i.e. with dedicated consistency).

I have no need for 'doctrine' in my life, but it's nice to have a very well-structured and well-organized approach to life. This can be done via 'religiousity' (dedicated rituals or consistent schedules).

I could use more 'religiousity' in my own life quite frankly.

I supposed I need to have 'faith' (expectation) that I can create more 'religiousity' (dedicated consistency) in my life. bigsmile

Then I guess I will have both faith and religion. laugh



well said! drinker

no photo
Fri 08/07/09 12:47 PM


Faith is strong, but without several other parts to go along with it, it isn't the strongest it could be. I have never really believed strongly in any religion until recently. Even now I don't aspire to any one religion I've seen. I do make it a point to try to study as much as I can about both history, philosophy, and religion; taking bits from each that make sense to the way I view my own experience. I feel that living life, is the only real way to prove any belief system or part of one correct. Though no one religion I've seen so far is entirely correct. Or they all are. So I'd say Faith is stronger even if that's all you have.

Ah but it is not.

I have faith, hope,... and love

and all the religions I have investigated do not fit reality well...

Many stories of impossible feats... Might as well be worshipping Thor or one of the other plethora of gods/goddesses.



Hey! Don't be bashing Thor worshippers now! laugh

Fusion99's photo
Fri 08/07/09 02:27 PM


Faith is strong, but without several other parts to go along with it, it isn't the strongest it could be. I have never really believed strongly in any religion until recently. Even now I don't aspire to any one religion I've seen. I do make it a point to try to study as much as I can about both history, philosophy, and religion; taking bits from each that make sense to the way I view my own experience. I feel that living life, is the only real way to prove any belief system or part of one correct. Though no one religion I've seen so far is entirely correct. Or they all are. So I'd say Faith is stronger even if that's all you have.

Ah but it is not.

I have faith, hope,... and love

and all the religions I have investigated do not fit reality well...

Many stories of impossible feats... Might as well be worshipping Thor or one of the other plethora of gods/goddesses.
You say none of the religions "fit" reality well, but you make the claim of having faith, hope and love.

Are the "trinity" that you spoke of not MAJOR expectations of several currently popular religions? Aren't some or all of your "trinity" classified as one of the seven cardinal virtues?

Are these not some of the highest aims of humans?

And haven't they all been rendered in some form in all religions?

Maybe you're just spoiled for choice?waving

AdventureBegins's photo
Fri 08/07/09 08:50 PM



Faith is strong, but without several other parts to go along with it, it isn't the strongest it could be. I have never really believed strongly in any religion until recently. Even now I don't aspire to any one religion I've seen. I do make it a point to try to study as much as I can about both history, philosophy, and religion; taking bits from each that make sense to the way I view my own experience. I feel that living life, is the only real way to prove any belief system or part of one correct. Though no one religion I've seen so far is entirely correct. Or they all are. So I'd say Faith is stronger even if that's all you have.

Ah but it is not.

I have faith, hope,... and love

and all the religions I have investigated do not fit reality well...

Many stories of impossible feats... Might as well be worshipping Thor or one of the other plethora of gods/goddesses.
You say none of the religions "fit" reality well, but you make the claim of having faith, hope and love.

Are the "trinity" that you spoke of not MAJOR expectations of several currently popular religions? Aren't some or all of your "trinity" classified as one of the seven cardinal virtues?

Are these not some of the highest aims of humans?

And haven't they all been rendered in some form in all religions?

Maybe you're just spoiled for choice?waving

If I explained to you my reasons for this I would insult some members on here. This I try to avoid.

WE the world.

My faith that it is a shining planet under the sun which shines in reality... that is my home.

and I share it with others...

Dragoness's photo
Fri 08/07/09 08:57 PM
I guess the question here would be faith in what?

Faith is to believe that something is going to happen for sure. Faith in what? Yourself?

Religion and faith can be synonymous but can also not be connected.

I have faith in alot of things and have no religion.

Ladylid2012's photo
Fri 08/07/09 09:05 PM

I guess the question here would be faith in what?

Faith is to believe that something is going to happen for sure. Faith in what? Yourself?

Religion and faith can be synonymous but can also not be connected.

I have faith in alot of things and have no religion.


faith in myself, faith in you, faith in humanity, faith in the power of love..the force of nature that love is, not the romantic view... and maybe the romantic view also
Faith that people are generally good, faith the there are no accidents,
so many things to have faith in..:heart:

wux's photo
Fri 08/07/09 09:23 PM
Religion is organized faith.

A whole bunch of people agree to have a faith in some ideals. Everyone who wants to join them is asked to believe in those ideals. Those who reject the same ideals are expelled from the group.

Some groups also ask their members not to believe in some other things.

Thus, you "must" believe may in the scriptures, one or more deity, and that the instructions how to worship them will bring results.

The "must not" believe things may include other gods, a world that is more than 7000 years old, and a round Earth. (This dogma changes its shape periodically, every few thousands of years.)

Fusion99's photo
Sat 08/08/09 07:34 AM




Faith is strong, but without several other parts to go along with it, it isn't the strongest it could be. I have never really believed strongly in any religion until recently. Even now I don't aspire to any one religion I've seen. I do make it a point to try to study as much as I can about both history, philosophy, and religion; taking bits from each that make sense to the way I view my own experience. I feel that living life, is the only real way to prove any belief system or part of one correct. Though no one religion I've seen so far is entirely correct. Or they all are. So I'd say Faith is stronger even if that's all you have.

Ah but it is not.

I have faith, hope,... and love

and all the religions I have investigated do not fit reality well...

Many stories of impossible feats... Might as well be worshipping Thor or one of the other plethora of gods/goddesses.
You say none of the religions "fit" reality well, but you make the claim of having faith, hope and love.

Are the "trinity" that you spoke of not MAJOR expectations of several currently popular religions? Aren't some or all of your "trinity" classified as one of the seven cardinal virtues?

Are these not some of the highest aims of humans?

And haven't they all been rendered in some form in all religions?

Maybe you're just spoiled for choice?waving

If I explained to you my reasons for this I would insult some members on here. This I try to avoid.

WE the world.

My faith that it is a shining planet under the sun which shines in reality... that is my home.

and I share it with others...
Your first sentence of your response is most intriguing!

The rest, I think, is meant for misdirection.

I see you want to avoid insult and anger, but you want to say something....

Kindred spirit;though fallen; Arise! and Evanesce the Word!laugh waving

Fusion99's photo
Sat 08/08/09 07:37 AM

Religion is organized faith.

A whole bunch of people agree to have a faith in some ideals. Everyone who wants to join them is asked to believe in those ideals. Those who reject the same ideals are expelled from the group.

Some groups also ask their members not to believe in some other things.

Thus, you "must" believe may in the scriptures, one or more deity, and that the instructions how to worship them will bring results.

The "must not" believe things may include other gods, a world that is more than 7000 years old, and a round Earth. (This dogma changes its shape periodically, every few thousands of years.)
Ummm....about the "round earth" comment, I don't consider spaceships and digital photography to be dogma.

I think we've proved without a doubt the earth is indeed round, well, it's a little squished at the poles...laugh laugh

no photo
Sun 08/09/09 12:07 PM


Religion is organized faith.

A whole bunch of people agree to have a faith in some ideals. Everyone who wants to join them is asked to believe in those ideals. Those who reject the same ideals are expelled from the group.

Some groups also ask their members not to believe in some other things.

Thus, you "must" believe may in the scriptures, one or more deity, and that the instructions how to worship them will bring results.

The "must not" believe things may include other gods, a world that is more than 7000 years old, and a round Earth. (This dogma changes its shape periodically, every few thousands of years.)
Ummm....about the "round earth" comment, I don't consider spaceships and digital photography to be dogma.

I think we've proved without a doubt the earth is indeed round, well, it's a little squished at the poles...laugh laugh


The actual shape is called an oblate spheroid, I believe.

Fusion99's photo
Sun 08/09/09 02:08 PM



Religion is organized faith.

A whole bunch of people agree to have a faith in some ideals. Everyone who wants to join them is asked to believe in those ideals. Those who reject the same ideals are expelled from the group.

Some groups also ask their members not to believe in some other things.

Thus, you "must" believe may in the scriptures, one or more deity, and that the instructions how to worship them will bring results.

The "must not" believe things may include other gods, a world that is more than 7000 years old, and a round Earth. (This dogma changes its shape periodically, every few thousands of years.)
Ummm....about the "round earth" comment, I don't consider spaceships and digital photography to be dogma.

I think we've proved without a doubt the earth is indeed round, well, it's a little squished at the poles...laugh laugh


The actual shape is called an oblate spheroid, I believe.
Sir, I do stand corrected!! to be honest, I hate Geometry and calculus...so round squished thing will have to do!!rofl rofl

no photo
Mon 08/10/09 11:08 AM




Religion is organized faith.

A whole bunch of people agree to have a faith in some ideals. Everyone who wants to join them is asked to believe in those ideals. Those who reject the same ideals are expelled from the group.

Some groups also ask their members not to believe in some other things.

Thus, you "must" believe may in the scriptures, one or more deity, and that the instructions how to worship them will bring results.

The "must not" believe things may include other gods, a world that is more than 7000 years old, and a round Earth. (This dogma changes its shape periodically, every few thousands of years.)
Ummm....about the "round earth" comment, I don't consider spaceships and digital photography to be dogma.

I think we've proved without a doubt the earth is indeed round, well, it's a little squished at the poles...laugh laugh


The actual shape is called an oblate spheroid, I believe.
Sir, I do stand corrected!! to be honest, I hate Geometry and calculus...so round squished thing will have to do!!rofl rofl


Works for me. :smile:

no photo
Mon 08/10/09 11:44 AM
AdventureBegins - the way you use language in this thread suggests to me that you understand something which few people seem to understand about the emotional experience of life, and the experience of love and faith.

I embrace the label 'weak atheist' for my view on the (non)existence of dieties. I see most everything related to religion as human-made. Still, I have faith, and faith is important to my life - though most people reading this are likely to misunderstand it, given the way that most people use that word.

Occsaoinally I have conversations with people who insist that the only acceptable use of the word faith requires that it is 'faith in' something; which may be valid given their experience of life and their experience of language use - but I think this is a sadly limited view.

You can love someone, you can love an object, you can feel loved, but a person can also experience love. Just love, without object, without an identified source.. Its a personal experience, related to a way of being, and a way of relating to yourself and everything. Similarly with faith. I don't know how to explain this, but I have experienced it. If I embraced Christianity I would use Christian metaphors to explain; a staunch materialist might bring up a discussion of brain chemistry. Many people like to box up everything with labels, even things they don't fully yet understand.

I know theists who have this faith (shown in other aspects of their existence), and whose strenght of faith is obviously closely related to their religious practice. And then there are people who somehow correlate 'strength of faith' to 'level of mindless insistence that a particular relgious dogma is true'. Reducing 'faith' to mere insistence on a claim, conviction - which is a fine use for the word, but a limited one, a sad one.

Really, its a trajedy - to think that this magnificent part of being alive 'having faith', is reduced to tool in meme warfare - becomes part of the pep rally cheering match of 'whose dogma is greater'. This wonderful experience is tied, wrongly, to allegiance to claims.

(Now Abra has said something about expectation. I haven't taken the time yet to think about this, but I suspect that the kind of faith I am speaking of is not only different from 'conviction', but also unrelated to expectation.)

no photo
Mon 08/10/09 11:49 AM

"Religion" is man-made.
"Faith" is God-made.

Which do you think is stronger?

...To answer your question in the context of Christianity.

But based on your own description of what you believe, AdventureBegins, what you call "faith" sounds a lot more like Existentialism; religion does not really relate.


What do you gain by categorizing his statements as 'sounding a lot more like Existentialism'? And what might you lose?

I do agree that religion need not relate; and it saddens me that so many only find the experience of faith through religion.

no photo
Mon 08/10/09 12:09 PM
I think I tend to agree with most here in that depending on how you define the concepts will determine your answers.

For me, faith is believing in something that cannot be proven (an of course this leads to a side topic of what is proof). Religion is how that belief is expressed, whether it is an individual's personal practices or an organized set of rituals.

I don't know if anyone else would agree with this because it means that someone with compulsive disorders would be classified as religious. They would have a very strong faith that something bad will happen if they do not do something, and their individual compulsions would be classified as a ritualistic expression of their faith.

So with these definitions, I don't think you can necessarily compare which is stronger. True, one leads to another but the idea is not necessarily more powerful than the practice.

I do not believe that you can have faith without religion. Whatever belief you embrace must be expressed in some fashion. Yet you can enact religious practices without the faith (How many of us were sent to church as children without knowing or feeling the faith behind the practice?)

I know, a little different than most of the opinions here but I am contrary by nature.

no photo
Mon 08/10/09 07:43 PM
Faith is a belief in something w/o proof. Period.
You can dress it up any way you want, make polite poetic prose about it, it's still a belief in something w/o proof. If you have proof, it's not faith. By definition.

I have no understanding why anyone would have faith in anything. It seems so completely intellectually lazy, I just cannot comprehend why any self-aware entity would indulge in this.

AdventureBegins's photo
Mon 08/10/09 08:46 PM

I guess the question here would be faith in what?

Faith is to believe that something is going to happen for sure. Faith in what? Yourself?

Religion and faith can be synonymous but can also not be connected.

I have faith in alot of things and have no religion.

I almost missed this... my humble bad.

I have faith in my self... But only human faith (which sometimes has doubt).

my foundational faith is in 'something' greater than I.

for I have seen creation in the moment... I have held a new born human in my hands.

and I have seen evolution in my grandchild who is quicker to learn and quicker to apply that knowledge...

I have a god like faith in the human race... We are.

AdventureBegins's photo
Mon 08/10/09 09:12 PM

what is it you believe in

all of you

Upon the earth.love

flowerforyou