1 3 Next
Topic: Can anyone answer this financial question?
s1owhand's photo
Fri 02/06/09 07:55 PM

1. In the representation that S1owhand gives, if there was total economic failure, and as others have equated, the entire world would suffer, then would those individuals (families) that, currently hold the greatest amount of the worlds wealth, also be in ruin?
2. If there were such a collapse in the U.S. and as others have equated, the entire world would suffer, then what value would ANY currency continue to hold, if any? Could the ‘American’ dollar become as useless as the civil war Confederate paper?

In other words would there ever be a time when money is so useless that barter is the only reliable and acceptable trade option?


1. those with the cash do NOT suffer in this scenario. they move to countries whose economies are healthy - the ones who are producers of valuable goods and big exporters. they have cash to lend and a very favorable market. they can and do demand spotless credit and ironclad guarantees of repayment and premium rates. they get it because they control the money. the whole world does not end in ruin...because as in Mad Max, someone always has valuable resources such as energy, weapons, food and ipods.

laugh

2. the currency of the producer/exporter states would not suffer because these valuable currencies would be required to purchase energy, weapons, food and ipods.

the USD can become essentially worthless if the US Govt goes under an we become South Canada or extreme northern Mexico...

laugh

a more realistic scenario is like the icelandic kronur,
the exchange rate gets cut in half. barter could indeed
become a dominant mode of transaction - see Somalia - but also it is worth noting that currency is still prized even in Somalia. that's why they have piracy and ransoms. the Somalis want USD and Euros to buy fun stuff like massage oil and condoms!

barter sign on mingle2:

"will pander for attention"

drinker

Jess642's photo
Sat 02/07/09 12:48 PM



In other words would there ever be a time when money is so useless that barter is the only reliable and acceptable trade option?




it is very possible.... and is not a difficult thing to set up... Di, have a look at the LETS scheme, used in Maleny, Queensland, Australia....an incredibly effective form of moneyless barter.

1 3 Next