Topic: Freud and the delusion of religion.
ljcc1964's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:12 AM
yawn

Jill298's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:13 AM
Spider... I would like to say that tho I rarely ever agree with you flowerforyou I do enjoy your posts and debating with you. You are one of the few well spoken and intelligent debaters in the religion threads. Alot of times you see people just blabbering on about non sense and getting all pissed laugh

no photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:15 AM



because it does hurt people. More people have been killed and more wars started in the name of God than for any other reason. In some religions, if you don't follow it just so... you get stoned to death. You can get shunned out of your family and community. One of the biggest problems is ( in my humble opinion) is that everyone seems to think their religion is right and all others are wrong. Take some of my family for example... if you don't believe exactly as they do, you will burn for all eternity in the depths of hell.


That's not true, simply look at the statistics on Democide and you will quickly see that more people have been killed in the name of "progress" than any religion. I suppose that if you accept Ann Coulter's belief that Liberalism is a religion, then your statement is still true, but I think most people would reject that belief.
Spider... look at the crusades? Look at the holy wars still going on to this day... You say it's "progress", I have to disagree.


I think you misunderstood my post.

In the 20th century, over 100 million people were killed by communism. These were deaths by Democide, which means they were killed by their own governments. They were killed in the name of "progress". For instance: A dam in China was allowed to collapse and kill the people in the valley, because the Communist government felt they were too much of a financial burden on the state. I didn't say that the religious wars were in the name of progress, sorry if I wasn't clear.

The crusades killed somewhere between 1 and 5 million, which is terrible and shouldn't be trivialized. But when compared to the numbers of people killed by Democide or in WWI/WWII, the numbers are dwarfed.

Jill298's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:16 AM
Edited by Jill298 on Wed 08/13/08 09:17 AM
religion has strong ties to people's idea of progress. Weren't the Jews killed in WWII simply because they were Jews?

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:17 AM
honestly i think the world would be a much better place if all organized religion went to the crapper.
most of the wars, though religiously overtoned had a lot of undertones as well. racism, the need for control.
religion was created to give guidelines for maorality.
i personally believe that by saying i dont believe in going to heaven or hell, but in living my life in away thats not going to harm myself or others i have become a better person.

religon was a attempt at guiding people when they werent as evolved, werent as sure of themselves. i think now we need to move past it and follow according to what we feel is socially right or worng.

Jill298's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:18 AM

honestly i think the world would be a much better place if all organized religion went to the crapper.
most of the wars, though religiously overtoned had a lot of undertones as well. racism, the need for control.
religion was created to give guidelines for maorality.
i personally believe that by saying i dont believe in going to heaven or hell, but in living my life in away thats not going to harm myself or others i have become a better person.

religon was a attempt at guiding people when they werent as evolved, werent as sure of themselves. i think now we need to move past it and follow according to what we feel is socially right or worng.
so we're going back to the dinosaurs then?laugh

no photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:19 AM
Hitler's WWII agenda was based on many things, Darwinism included. You might as well chalk WWII up to science as religion. Hitler and his followers were devoted to the idea of evolution, they believed that Darwin was right in calling blacks "anthropomorphic apes" and they conducted experiments to try to breed black women with apes. I always see the religious components of Hitler's ideology discussed, but people are rarely willing to discuss his obsession with Darwinism and genetic purity as a cause of WWII.

Jill298's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:20 AM
are people not being killed in Isreal right now because of religious clashes? and fights over who's holy land it is...

Jill298's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:22 AM
All I am saying is that millions upon millions of people have been and will be killed over religion. Whether or not that is the complete reason is up for debate, however there are strong religious ties to a good portion of it.

ljcc1964's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:23 AM




I'm not sure what your point is here. Can you please elaborate?


Upside-down Red-head ... blushing Does it get better than that? :heart:

I just reckon that there is pre-conditioning to being slave to religion and it takes strength to move away from it.


Are you asserting, then, that if you are religious, that you are therefor a slave to it...and that it is something that you must move away from by some stregnth that you must somehow find, preferably within yourself? happy


Depending on your religious upbringings you will be a slave to your religion.

If you see that the upbringing has so many contradictions that make it impossible to live comfortably with then the strength you need is to break from you peer-group.

Humans like to be part of a group. We are very social animals and when we move against the tide of normality, our peers start to question us, as it is not "normal"


Well...I think it is more likely that we "think" we have people figure out....than any actuality that we do. It's really more arrogance for anyone to feel that he/she sits so far above everyone else that he/she can accurately proclaim what box each person fits into. Especially when the proclaimer doesn't know the person(s).

Hey!! Who wants pie??

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:26 AM

are people not being killed in Isreal right now because of religious clashes? and fights over who's holy land it is...

yes but ur losing the point. thats wrong. everyone is in agreement that that is wrong. the point is that religon, while it has its good points was created so that people could have a better understanding of themselves as well as begining to understand the difference between right and wrong.
in a lot of religions we are still living in the age of the dinosaurs because no one is willing to compromise and or admit theyare wrong.
yes, people kill people under the guise of religion. but if you dig under the surface it isnt really religion at all. its oil, its control, its power and money and psychopaths.

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:27 AM





I'm not sure what your point is here. Can you please elaborate?


Upside-down Red-head ... blushing Does it get better than that? :heart:

I just reckon that there is pre-conditioning to being slave to religion and it takes strength to move away from it.


Are you asserting, then, that if you are religious, that you are therefor a slave to it...and that it is something that you must move away from by some stregnth that you must somehow find, preferably within yourself? happy


Depending on your religious upbringings you will be a slave to your religion.

If you see that the upbringing has so many contradictions that make it impossible to live comfortably with then the strength you need is to break from you peer-group.

Humans like to be part of a group. We are very social animals and when we move against the tide of normality, our peers start to question us, as it is not "normal"


Well...I think it is more likely that we "think" we have people figure out....than any actuality that we do. It's really more arrogance for anyone to feel that he/she sits so far above everyone else that he/she can accurately proclaim what box each person fits into. Especially when the proclaimer doesn't know the person(s).

Hey!! Who wants pie??


i want pie!

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:31 AM

religion has strong ties to people's idea of progress. Weren't the Jews killed in WWII simply because they were Jews?

and gypsies were killed because they were gypsies and homoexuals because they were gay, as well as twins being eperimented on to test the bonds between them.

ljcc1964's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:34 AM






I'm not sure what your point is here. Can you please elaborate?


Upside-down Red-head ... blushing Does it get better than that? :heart:

I just reckon that there is pre-conditioning to being slave to religion and it takes strength to move away from it.


Are you asserting, then, that if you are religious, that you are therefor a slave to it...and that it is something that you must move away from by some stregnth that you must somehow find, preferably within yourself? happy


Depending on your religious upbringings you will be a slave to your religion.

If you see that the upbringing has so many contradictions that make it impossible to live comfortably with then the strength you need is to break from you peer-group.

Humans like to be part of a group. We are very social animals and when we move against the tide of normality, our peers start to question us, as it is not "normal"


Well...I think it is more likely that we "think" we have people figure out....than any actuality that we do. It's really more arrogance for anyone to feel that he/she sits so far above everyone else that he/she can accurately proclaim what box each person fits into. Especially when the proclaimer doesn't know the person(s).

Hey!! Who wants pie??


i want pie!


Big or little slice? happy

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:35 AM
big! all this typig is sappig my energy!...wait what kind?

ljcc1964's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:36 AM

big! all this typig is sappig my energy!...wait what kind?

I got banana cream, pecan and apple.

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:37 AM
oh and, the jews arent just considered a different religion they are considered a race of people as well.
so the jews werent just killed because of their religious views but because they were a different race and hitler was trying to purify the germans. drinker

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:38 AM


big! all this typig is sappig my energy!...wait what kind?

I got banana cream, pecan and apple.

pecan please!yum!

no photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:39 AM


big! all this typig is sappig my energy!...wait what kind?

I got banana cream, pecan and apple.


Banana cream please. And pecan... You better just give me a slice of all three.

sara89's photo
Wed 08/13/08 09:40 AM



big! all this typig is sappig my energy!...wait what kind?

I got banana cream, pecan and apple.


Banana cream please. And pecan... You better just give me a slice of all three.

here heredrinker bigsmile