Topic: Top 5 Guitarists?
messi_is_a_tim_1888's photo
Sun 02/22/15 03:37 AM
My missus said what about Pete Townsend and Keith Richards?

MadDog1974's photo
Sun 02/22/15 03:56 AM

My missus said what about Pete Townsend and Keith Richards?


I love them both, but I stand by my choices. Honestly, if anything, this discussion only proves that a top 5, 10, or even 20 list is going to have someone unhappy with the list. But it is fun to discuss.

no photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:04 AM

Great topic man.....

Slash
Jimmy page
Jimi Hendrix
Tony Iommi
Carlos Santana


This list but I'd have to squeeze Peter Frampton in there some place.

no photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:05 AM

Great topic man.....

Slash
Jimmy page
Jimi Hendrix
Tony Iommi
Carlos Santana


This list but I'd have to squeeze Peter Frampton in there some place.

ShadowHawke's photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:27 AM
STEVE VAI
JOE SATRIANI
AXEL RUDI PELL
BRIAN MAY
ERIC JOHNSON.


STEVE VAI is the GOD of guitar

Argo's photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:32 AM
maddog, with so many names being passed out, you should have titled this....
........"name a great guitarist in alphabetical order"

A--angus young
B--bb king
C--carlos santana
D--duane allman
E--eric clapton...........................<<< that's a pretty good top-5 right there

no photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:33 AM


Great topic man.....

Slash
Jimmy page
Jimi Hendrix
Tony Iommi
Carlos Santana


This list but I'd have to squeeze Peter Frampton in there some place.

Yep, forgot about him, even just for 'Frampton comes alive' he deserves to be on the list.

MadDog1974's photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:49 AM

maddog, with so many names being passed out, you should have titled this....
........"name a great guitarist in alphabetical order"

A--angus young
B--bb king
C--carlos santana
D--duane allman
E--eric clapton...........................<<< that's a pretty good top-5 right there


That's not a bad idea, but even doing it that way would start a debate. This is at least a debate where we can agree that some very worthy names have been mentioned. And frankly, I've noticed some that I'm surprised no one has mentioned, but I'll let someone bring them up. Of all the names thrown out there so far, I would only argue against one of them. Some of the names mentioned were hard to leave off the list. Others were easy. I didn't include some of my favorites because, truthfully, just because I like them doesn't mean they are the best. Ace Frehley, for example. He's good, and he's my favorite, but he's not not top 10 good, and the only reason he would make a top 20 is because he is my favorite.

Argo's photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:55 AM
lol....only you could start a debate about alphabetical order...laugh

messi_is_a_tim_1888's photo
Sun 02/22/15 04:57 AM
The Edge, Jeff Beck, Mark Knofler, Chuck Berry, John Lennon, etc. We could be here all day long?

technovative's photo
Sun 02/22/15 06:13 AM
Eric Johnson
Nuno Bettencourt
Stevie Ray Vaughan
Jerry Reed
Ty Tabor

MadDog1974's photo
Sun 02/22/15 06:15 AM
Edited by MadDog1974 on Sun 02/22/15 06:17 AM
Jerry Reed came out of nowhere, but I like that list.

And on the previous list, Chuck Berry is the real King of Rock and Roll, but maybe we can discuss that on another thread.

no photo
Sun 02/22/15 06:26 AM
Jimi Hendrix
Eric Clapton
Kurt Cobain
Satriani
Paul Simon

and...Carlos Santana without a doubt.


Argo's photo
Sun 02/22/15 06:33 AM
here's five more....

ry cooder
earl klugh
billy gibbons
wes montgomery
andres segovia

Sherilynn2's photo
Sun 02/22/15 07:25 AM
women rock! :banana:

joan jett
nancy wilson
bonnie raitt

Argo's photo
Sun 02/22/15 07:37 AM
there are so many....but just one more i can't pass on........albert king...

this cat plays a right-handed guitar, left handed without restringing it, in other
words, backwards....high E on the top, low E on the bottom....may be a couple of others, who play this way, but i can't remember their names...

technovative's photo
Sun 02/22/15 07:48 AM
Female Guitarists:

Lita Ford
Bonnie Raitt
Shannon Curfman
Charo
Vicki Peterson (the Bangles)

MadDog1974's photo
Sun 02/22/15 10:09 AM

there are so many....but just one more i can't pass on........albert king...

this cat plays a right-handed guitar, left handed without restringing it, in other
words, backwards....high E on the top, low E on the bottom....may be a couple of others, who play this way, but i can't remember their names...


You've made a convincing enough point that James Burton has just been replaced on my list. Great call! And the women who have been named are hard to argue against, but Nancy Wilson remains the only woman in my top 5. Some of those could possibly find themselves in my top 10 or 20 though. I'm still surprised by some names that not being mentioned by anyone. Eddie Van Halen, most notably, even though I'm glad no one has considered him.

mysticalview21's photo
Sun 02/22/15 01:50 PM
Edited by mysticalview21 on Sun 02/22/15 01:52 PM

women rock! :banana:

joan jett
nancy wilson
bonnie raitt



cool !

Prince and way to many other men out there to name ...and some named already ... not sure if I saw the Boss... saw BB King...

DonnyRover's photo
Mon 02/23/15 04:33 AM
There are loads I could mention, some mentioned here already but my top five if pressed would be:
Joe Satriani
Steve Vai
Brian May
Jeff Hennerman
Kerry King