Topic: Another planetary thought or question.
izzyphoto1977's photo
Fri 01/10/14 12:30 PM
I'm watching this show called how the universe works and they are talking about how if two stars are close enough when one starts to die it will steal food from the other star.

Stars burn hydrogen as I recall and Jupiter is hydrogen gas and a lot of it. So since there aren't any stars close enough for the sun to steal from. Might it start sucking up the gases from Jupiter and perhaps other gas based planets to live longer?

Another thought is if it started to do that might it also ignite the gas it is stealing and then turn Jupiter into a star?

I actually had this thought once before and since my Mars thread had such an interesting result. I figured why not ask this one sinc eI was reminded about it from watching this show.

hmlover's photo
Fri 01/10/14 12:36 PM
I had always understood that stars go through a giant phase before they reach the point that you're referring to. If that happens, how big will the sun get? Will Jupiter have already been absorbed in that phase?

izzyphoto1977's photo
Fri 01/10/14 12:39 PM
That is correct from what they say. Perhaps Jupiter would be ignited from one of the phases of the sun expanding. I just kind of wonder if Jupiter would be more likely to be eaten by the sun or turned into a star?

vanaheim's photo
Fri 01/10/14 06:22 PM
You need the victim star's atmosphere to be bigger diameter than the lagrange point (the balance of neutral gravity between them).

This can happen in a binary system where one star is a giant.
Or in a binary where one has a prodigous gravity well, like a captured stellar remnant in close proximity.

mightymoe's photo
Fri 01/10/14 06:43 PM

You need the victim star's atmosphere to be bigger diameter than the lagrange point (the balance of neutral gravity between them).

This can happen in a binary system where one star is a giant.
Or in a binary where one has a prodigous gravity well, like a captured stellar remnant in close proximity.



correct, the greater gravity always wins... if Jupiter would have been around 10 times bigger, it probably would be a brown dwarf, there would be enough gravity pressure at the core tho start the reaction

izzyphoto1977's photo
Fri 01/10/14 06:47 PM


You need the victim star's atmosphere to be bigger diameter than the lagrange point (the balance of neutral gravity between them).

This can happen in a binary system where one star is a giant.
Or in a binary where one has a prodigous gravity well, like a captured stellar remnant in close proximity.



correct, the greater gravity always wins... if Jupiter would have been around 10 times bigger, it probably would be a brown dwarf, there would be enough gravity pressure at the core tho start the reaction



Are you talking about for it to be eaten by the sun or for it to eat the sun?

mightymoe's photo
Fri 01/10/14 06:55 PM



You need the victim star's atmosphere to be bigger diameter than the lagrange point (the balance of neutral gravity between them).

This can happen in a binary system where one star is a giant.
Or in a binary where one has a prodigous gravity well, like a captured stellar remnant in close proximity.



correct, the greater gravity always wins... if Jupiter would have been around 10 times bigger, it probably would be a brown dwarf, there would be enough gravity pressure at the core tho start the reaction



Are you talking about for it to be eaten by the sun or for it to eat the sun?


no, for it to become a minor star... it will take billions of years for jupiter to get eaten by the sun... seems more likely it would turn into a star before it gets eaten by one...

izzyphoto1977's photo
Fri 01/10/14 07:00 PM
I guess then it would be a fight between Jupiter and the sun as to which one ate the other then at that point. Care to place any bets? hahaha

mightymoe's photo
Fri 01/10/14 07:03 PM

I guess then it would be a fight between Jupiter and the sun as to which one ate the other then at that point. Care to place any bets? hahaha


lol, bet on the sun....

izzyphoto1977's photo
Fri 01/10/14 07:08 PM
I'll take Jupiter then. Guess we'll have to live for ever or our souls will have to keep in contact to collect. hahaha