Topic: Teacher Emphasizes Old-Fashioned Etiquette
franshade's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:01 PM




It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?

The kids

Robm248's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:06 PM





It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?

The kids

A little of that might happen. However, I think first we need to change how we as a society act. Instead of this 'me' culture we have, we need to develop a culture of respect for others and concern with doing what is right. I guess this is a start, but unless we have a big culture shift I do not see it passing to many other people. Sadly.

franshade's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:08 PM






It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?

The kids

A little of that might happen. However, I think first we need to change how we as a society act. Instead of this 'me' culture we have, we need to develop a culture of respect for others and concern with doing what is right. I guess this is a start, but unless we have a big culture shift I do not see it passing to many other people. Sadly.


Start by example, but I can see where you are coming from. We can all learn from others if we just pay attention and make wise decisions.

Robm248's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:11 PM







It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?

The kids

A little of that might happen. However, I think first we need to change how we as a society act. Instead of this 'me' culture we have, we need to develop a culture of respect for others and concern with doing what is right. I guess this is a start, but unless we have a big culture shift I do not see it passing to many other people. Sadly.


Start by example, but I can see where you are coming from. We can all learn from others if we just pay attention and make wise decisions.


I try. Not that I do so perfectly, but I do small things like holding doors for people. I get a lot of 'thank you's... and then a lot of doors slammed in my face! Gotta love it!

Dragoness's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:13 PM


You really want old fashioned? Victorian era or Colonial? Take your pick. Read about how women had to act back then. Women are fortunate to have what they do today, I don't think they want to return to the old ways. I'd love to see the schools try to pull this stunt in Los Angeles or Philadelphia. Let me know how it goes.


Nobody wants "old fashioned"...life moves not backwards nor tarries for yesterday. There is nothing wrong with this type of program as long as it is optional. Women are fortunate..to have human basic rights as being treated respectfully.
Yes, maybe so, shame it took a couple hundred years. It's going to continue to evolve..were not done yet! Hell, were just getting started.


We are just getting started...lol

Just because a man acts gentlemanly doesn't mean we have to return to a time when women were abused more than today.

Treating a woman as a woman doesn't mean she has to be treated as less than a man at any level.

franshade's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:13 PM
Rob you can open my door anytime :wink:

People just misunderstand common courtesy and manners. You keep doing what you think and know to be the right thing to do, someone may just see you opening the door for others and do the same.

flowerforyou

Ladylid2012's photo
Mon 02/22/10 05:13 PM
Of course it would be best if parents taught children...in many ways we do, by example. The kids are at school so much of their day, they learn all kinds of things that aren't about the "3 R's"
Think about the garbage your kids came home saying and doing after they started school..My oldest came home with new swear words, 2nd grade he came home and asked what a "faggot" was...

So why not put some energy into them learning some good things too. If some parents aren't reinforcing such things doesn't have to mean the child can't benefit from it. Many of these kids who are not being taught a positive message at home.. want the positive, they need it.
And can carry it with them through their lives.

Maybe it's the kids who don't have the positive reinforcement at home that could benefit from it the most.

Winx's photo
Mon 02/22/10 07:14 PM
Edited by Winx on Mon 02/22/10 07:21 PM

A lost art?

Women want equality why should the boys treat them different than the way they treat other boys?


It's called good manners and respect. Having some class.

I've taught my child good manners, open doors for the elderly, etc. I didn't tell them to only have good manners if the people were of a certain sex.

Btw, my child was at a church function. I listened to the last ten minutes of it. The leader was talking to the children about opening doors for people. He said that they should do that because those people are God's children too and we treat God's children well. That was the jist of it. I thought that was a cool way of looking at it.



yellowrose10's photo
Mon 02/22/10 07:19 PM




It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?


well that is a problem. You can't force adults to learn manners. Even with leading by example...if an adult doesn't care or thinks they aren't wrong, they won't learn

cashu's photo
Mon 02/22/10 08:27 PM

How much ya wanna bet that, at some point in the near future, the ACLU sues the school because the teacher might have some students whose religion dictates that women are inferior to men.
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoo
how much do you want to bet those kids that leran to be so polite never get a date ..well be the kids that the rest of school kid in the *** every day .

cashu's photo
Mon 02/22/10 08:35 PM






It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?

The kids

A little of that might happen. However, I think first we need to change how we as a society act. Instead of this 'me' culture we have, we need to develop a culture of respect for others and concern with doing what is right. I guess this is a start, but unless we have a big culture shift I do not see it passing to many other people. Sadly.
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
uh that's called ethics and all the great philosophers wondered if it was good. Why don't we teach it in school .

Ladylid2012's photo
Mon 02/22/10 08:39 PM


How much ya wanna bet that, at some point in the near future, the ACLU sues the school because the teacher might have some students whose religion dictates that women are inferior to men.
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoo
how much do you want to bet those kids that leran to be so polite never get a date ..well be the kids that the rest of school kid in the *** every day .


That's a crock of shiit!

I have 3 grown up sons now and they were then and are now polite, respectful, door opening, excuse me saying, gentlemen. They don't take any crap from anyone and they didn't take crap or get bullied then. They get dates and are confident young men.

What is with this misconception that if you exhibit manners and are polite and kind to women it makes you a pU88y....I'm not understanding this thinking.

cashu's photo
Mon 02/22/10 08:42 PM

Good for this teacher.I was also raised that way and I still open doors for women and give up my seat for them if I am riding a bus or a train.It really makes their day and I get nice complements from them.Once in a while I open a door for a girl and she gives me a dirty look and says "I can do that myself".One time I was riding a crowded bus and this lady asked this man sitting if he wouldn't mind giving up his seat for her.He said "thats what woman rights gets your a**" and got back to reading his paper.I couldn't help but to start laughing like most of the people around us did.
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
well this is the simple reason but it started back in the earle 60's . they didn't want to be treated like a lady . so now they get what there grandmothers wanted . freedom to find there own sit ect . and that funny look was she was wondering if you were going to demand sex for opening the door .

Ladylid2012's photo
Mon 02/22/10 08:58 PM





It's not a bad idea for the schools to teach etiquette, but unless the parents reinforce it, it won't be effective. It does need to start at home. Too many parents these days want everyone else to do their jobs for them.


I agree, it does START at home, but school is a great environment to Re inforce it.


I agree. In other words, it seems to be backwards. It starts at home and the school can help reinforce it. Not that they teach it and the parents think that is good enough


Only one problem with this... who's going to teach all those parent's who never bothered to learn?


well that is a problem. You can't force adults to learn manners. Even with leading by example...if an adult doesn't care or thinks they aren't wrong, they won't learn


I think that were under estimating these kids. If a kid isn't getting taught manners, integrity, or anything positive at home there is a pretty good chance they are already looking else where for positive reinforcement. My father was the biggest racist I have ever known..really, in my entire life. I didn't grow up being a racist. I watched others and learned from them. Parents influence is strong to a point..then a child figures it out on their own. I've seen some pretty good kids come out of some pretty bad homes.

yellowrose10's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:00 PM
I'm not underestimating them at all. I realize kids can learn even if their parents are wrong, but it is hard to install manners in them when they go home and the parents don't have manners themselves. They see mom and dad acting a certain way. Not saying it's not possible, just saying it makes it harder when it doesn't start at home. JMO

Winx's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:04 PM


How much ya wanna bet that, at some point in the near future, the ACLU sues the school because the teacher might have some students whose religion dictates that women are inferior to men.
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOoo
how much do you want to bet those kids that leran to be so polite never get a date ..well be the kids that the rest of school kid in the *** every day .


Whatever are you talking about? Almost all of the men that I know have good manners like that. Even men that I don't know open the door for me and my child when we go to the store. Are you saying that none of them can get dates? I need to let my father, brother, and my ex boyfriends know that.laugh My own child has learned, by my example, to say excuse me, thank you, etc. to the cashier, the waitress, and everybody else.

Winx's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:05 PM

I'm not underestimating them at all. I realize kids can learn even if their parents are wrong, but it is hard to install manners in them when they go home and the parents don't have manners themselves. They see mom and dad acting a certain way. Not saying it's not possible, just saying it makes it harder when it doesn't start at home. JMO


Rose,

Can't peer pressure go a long way? Even if that peer pressure is good manners?

yellowrose10's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:07 PM


I'm not underestimating them at all. I realize kids can learn even if their parents are wrong, but it is hard to install manners in them when they go home and the parents don't have manners themselves. They see mom and dad acting a certain way. Not saying it's not possible, just saying it makes it harder when it doesn't start at home. JMO


Rose,

Can't peer pressure go a long way? Even if that peer pressure is good manners?


yes....but depends on ages too. But this is my opinion and you are welcome to yours

Ladylid2012's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:09 PM

I'm not underestimating them at all. I realize kids can learn even if their parents are wrong, but it is hard to install manners in them when they go home and the parents don't have manners themselves. They see mom and dad acting a certain way. Not saying it's not possible, just saying it makes it harder when it doesn't start at home. JMO


I agree..it does make it harder. A lot more challenges for the kids, absolutely. That's the time the rest of us kinda fill in ya know. I know with me and the age spans between my boys..I have ALWAYS had a house full of boys and many of them would spend a lot of time here. They felt comfortable and safe, some would spend days in a row with us. Those are the times I took full advantage of letting them vent, listening, giving advise, if asked. Now I have some who come over 10 years later, now in their 20's and tell me some little story that I shared with them, and how if affected their life. I don't even remember most of the things they say, but they remembered and somehow it helped them. So the littlest thing out side of the influence of "bad parents" does make a difference to some of these kids.

yellowrose10's photo
Mon 02/22/10 09:13 PM
Lori,

I have a 10yr old cousin (Ryan)...his mom is a piece of work. No matter what the family tries and the school tries to teach him about being sociable and how to act right with people....it doesn't matter. He looks to his mom and even though he knows it's wrong, he follows his mom's lead.

Kids are individuals and are different. Some may learn, some might follow the parents lead. Tough call. (just look at my neighbors lol)

I am not saying to stop the classes at all, just saying I wish some parents these days would stop expecting others to do their jobs