Previous 1
Topic: Court orders Mn file sharer to pay RIAA $1.92 million
ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 08:23 PM


Court orders Jammie Thomas to pay RIAA $1.92 million

by Greg Sandoval
June 18, 2009 2:48 PM PDT


Jammie Thomas-Rasset was found guilty of willful copyright infringement on Thursday in a Minneapolis federal court and must pay the recording industry $1.92 million.

In a surprise decision, the jury imposed damages against Thomas-Rasset, who was originally accused to sharing more than 1,700 songs, at a whopping $80,000 for each of the 24 songs she was ultimately found guilty of illegally sharing..

In 2007, the Recording Industry Association of America claimed in a lawsuit that Thomas-Rasset pilfered 1,700 songs. The RIAA eventually culled that number down to a representative sample of 24.

Thomas-Rasset lost a previous trial in October 2007 when a jury rendered a $222,000 verdict against the Minnesota native. U.S. District Judge Michael David threw out the decision after acknowledging he erred when giving his jury instructions.

According to Ars Technica reporter Nate Anderson, Thomas-Rasset gasped when the dollar amount was read in court.

For the four largest recording companies, the jury's decision is an affirmation of the legality of the industry's copyright claims.

"We appreciate the jury's service and that they take this issue as seriously as we do," said Cara Duckworth, an RIAA spokeswoman. "We are pleased that the jury agreed with the evidence and found the defendant liable. Since day 1, we have been willing to settle the case and remain willing to do so."

According to Ben Sheffner, a copyright advocate and former attorney for 20th Century Fox who attended the entire hearing, one of Thomas' attorneys is willing to discuss a settlement with the music industry.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-10268199-93.html?part=rss&subj=news&tag=2547-1_3-0-5

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 08:27 PM
It is ashame that someone must be the scapegoat...but we have been warned over and over again to stop.

Kat

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 08:34 PM

It is ashame that someone must be the scapegoat...but we have been warned over and over again to stop.

Kat


The RIAA refuses to listen to their customers. The music industry is dying because 90% of the stuff that passes as music these days is sh1t. And even that sh1t is not original but a copy cat of someone else's feces. If music was more worth purchasing and much cheaper maybe they would not be in such terrible shape. They are in reality losing very little $ to file sharing. Many see a model where music is free and artists make their money by touring and selling related merchandise.

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:01 PM
Thomas I am just saying that we have been warned to stop this behavior. I am constantly telling my nieces and nephews to not do it because they could get caught and be arrested. Pay huge fines.

I dont even care about whether the music is sh!t or not. If it's so much sh!t, then why download it anyway?

It is stealing when they make their money with cd's and such. And the illegal downloading takes that away. Even if it is mere pennies.

Like I said...I don't care. If I want music...I turn on the radio. Or tune the tv to a music channel. Besides...there is legal downloads out there.

Kat

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:12 PM

Thomas I am just saying that we have been warned to stop this behavior. I am constantly telling my nieces and nephews to not do it because they could get caught and be arrested. Pay huge fines.

I dont even care about whether the music is sh!t or not. If it's so much sh!t, then why download it anyway?

It is stealing when they make their money with cd's and such. And the illegal downloading takes that away. Even if it is mere pennies.

Like I said...I don't care. If I want music...I turn on the radio. Or tune the tv to a music channel. Besides...there is legal downloads out there.

Kat


Is it lost revenue if I would have never ever purchased it?

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:16 PM
Like I said...I don't even buy any of them. I think I have maybe 5 cd's and they were either bought for me or given to me.

If you don't buy you don't buy. Their loss. But if you steal..it is against the law.

Kat

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:18 PM
ahhhhh grasshoppa....as the wise Kat foretold...it is a theft of the music to your ears bigsmile

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:22 PM
Edited by ThomasJB on Thu 06/18/09 09:23 PM
Oh well. I'm already too far down the highway to hell to turn back now. pitchfork devil

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:23 PM

Oh well. I'm already too far down the highway to hell to turn back now. pitchfork devil


fried grasshoppa huh?

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:24 PM

Oh well. I'm already too far down the highway to hell to turn back now. pitchfork devil


lol lol, but...we like you anyway.:wink:

Kat

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:25 PM


Oh well. I'm already too far down the highway to hell to turn back now. pitchfork devil


lol lol, but...we like you anyway.:wink:

Kat


we do???? I didn't get the memo grumble
biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:25 PM
Is it hot in here is is just me? :laughing:

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:28 PM



Oh well. I'm already too far down the highway to hell to turn back now. pitchfork devil


lol lol, but...we like you anyway.:wink:

Kat


we do???? I didn't get the memo grumble
biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin biggrin


[ memo...] " we like Thomas"...soreeeee...


yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:30 PM
well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:31 PM

well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh


Damn Texas women are so backwards! bigsmile

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:33 PM


well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh


Damn Texas women are so backwards! bigsmile


i thought you like us that....oh never mind blushing

ThomasJB's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:34 PM



well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh


Damn Texas women are so backwards! bigsmile


i thought you like us that....oh never mind blushing


Backwards, frontwards, sidewards and upside down. :wink: bigsmile

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:35 PM
see??? I told Fran angles are good laugh oops

scttrbrain's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:37 PM

well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh


Trust me???blushing :wink:

Nite all. I am tired. Ill check back tomorning to see if you all survived.

Kat

yellowrose10's photo
Thu 06/18/09 09:38 PM


well Kat...too little too late don't ya think??? besides...that memo isn't notarized...how do I know it's legit? laugh


Trust me???blushing :wink:

Nite all. I am tired. Ill check back tomorning to see if you all survived.

Kat


nite nite Kat

Previous 1